定语从句的一道题

来源：百度知道 编辑：UC知道 时间：2024/05/14 13:45:24
The policemen were sure that the murderer was the man_____gun was found beside the dead body.
A.who had B.whose C.which D.of whom a
答案是B 可我想问的是为什么不能选A
注意不是为什么选B,是为什么不能选A!
如果选A,题目应该怎么改.

如果选A的话那么这个定语从句的从句中就会有两套主语和谓语，“who had”和“gun was found”,很明显不符合语法规则。若硬要选A，可将“was found”去掉，符合语法规则，但不免有牵强之意。

whose gun 谁的枪
who gun 说不通啊

B
因为从句中已经有动词了，所以答案中不需要动词！

如果选A,后面的who had gun was found beside the dead body补充说明前面的,它肯定不能是独立的一个完整句子,可是这里面有WAS,就不可能是一个补语,一个句子不可能有两个谓语动词,所以HAD,WAS,不能同时出现

选A就没有意义了

那语文上不就叫句式杂糅了呗~
要么是:The policemen were sure that the murderer was the man who had gun.
要么是：The policemen were sure that the murderer was the man whose gun was found beside the dead body.